The Power of Reflection: An
Exploration of Its Role in Learning and Teaching
Mariam Farooq, University of
Saskatchewan
Author’s Note
Mariam Farooq
https://orcid.org/0000-0002-4196-4522
The author declares no conflicts of interest and has no
acknowledgments to declare.
Correspondence concerning this article should be addressed to Mariam Farooq at qpm628@usask.ca
Abstract
This autoethnographic exploration
traces my evolving understanding and practice of reflective writing,
highlighting its significance in both personal and professional contexts.
Initially, my exposure to reflective practices within South Africa’s education
system, and later as a university student, was surface level, with minimal
guidance on engaging meaningfully in reflection. My early reflections were
largely descriptive, recounting events rather than critically analysing them.
It was during my Master of Education programme, while conducting action
research to develop students’ writing skills through portfolios, that I began
to engage deeply in reflection, both as a student and as an educator
facilitating reflective practices in others. Through this process, I realised
that reflection requires explicit instruction and consistent practice,
particularly in educational contexts that prioritise rote memorisation over
critical thinking. As a university educator, I revised my approach to teaching
reflection by incorporating guiding questions, peer review activities, and
technology-based platforms to foster deeper engagement. This shift
significantly improved students' reflective abilities, especially in fields
such as nursing and education. Now, as a PhD student, reflection remains a
central tool in my academic growth and research journey. Overall, this
self-reflective journey highlights the importance of intentional and structured
approaches to teaching reflection, ensuring it serves its transformative
purpose in education by fostering critical thinking, self-awareness, and
lifelong learning.
Keywords: critical thinking, higher education,
life experiences, reflective writing
In
today's rapidly evolving educational landscape, the ability to reflect
critically on one's experiences, beliefs, and learning processes is
increasingly recognised as a key competency for success in higher education
(Ryan, 2015; Sudirman et al., 2024).
Reflective practice allows students to engage with their thoughts, emotions,
and behaviours, linking academic experiences to real-world contexts. This
process not only enables students to build on their current skills but also
helps them identify areas for improvement and gain a deeper understanding of
themselves as learners (Adie & Tangen, 2014; Taylor, 2023).
Reflection is a cognitive process that involves the
deliberate consideration of experiences, actions, and outcomes, leading to
deeper understanding and insight (Crane & Sosulski, 2020). The benefits of reflective
activities have contributed to their growing popularity in higher education.
Through metacognition, students can develop a better understanding of their
learning preferences, strengths, and areas of challenge (Bharuthram,
2018). Additionally, reflective writing offers students the opportunity to
connect theory to practice, thereby providing a platform for applying newly
acquired knowledge to real-world settings.
A key component of effective reflective writing is the
balance between descriptive writing and critical reflection. This balance
allows students to go beyond merely recounting experiences to deeply analyse
them, thereby maximising the impact of reflection (Ash & Clayton, 2009; Pais
Marden & Herrington, 2022). Moreover, reflection encourages students to
question why they hold certain views rather than simply stating their opinions,
fostering stronger analytical skills.
The exploration in this
article is guided by the research question: How has my understanding of reflective writing evolved, and how can I
help students develop effective reflective writing skills?
I
was born in Karachi, Pakistan, and moved to Johannesburg, South Africa, at the
age of ten. Completing most of my schooling and earning my bachelor’s degree in
South Africa provided me with a diverse academic and cultural foundation that
deeply influences my worldview and pedagogical approaches. Growing up and
studying in different cultural contexts exposed me to varied educational
philosophies.
After completing my undergraduate studies, I returned to
Pakistan and began teaching at a primary school. During these early years of
teaching, I experienced numerous 'Aha' moments that inspired me to take risks,
explore new possibilities, and push boundaries in my quest for both personal
and professional growth. These moments became the foundation of my teaching
philosophy: that educators, through empathy and reflection, can drive positive
change in their students' lives. This belief deeply shaped how I approached
teaching and how I encouraged my students to reflect on their own learning
experiences.
After two years of teaching, I pursued a master’s degree
in education, further deepening my understanding of pedagogical theories and
reflective practices. Soon after, I began teaching English for Academic
Purposes (EAP) courses at the university level. Over the course of ten years, I
guided undergraduate and graduate students in reflecting on their academic
journeys, encouraging them to connect their personal experiences with
theoretical learning. These experiences solidified my belief in the importance
of reflective writing as a critical tool for both academic and personal growth.
In September 2023, I moved to Canada as an international
student to pursue a PhD in Curriculum Studies. This shift allowed me to reflect
deeply on my own learning process, especially as I navigated the role of a
student once again in a new cultural and academic environment. My academic journey,
both as a teacher and a student, has reinforced the vital role reflection plays
in creating meaningful learning experiences. This positionality shapes the lens
through which I examine and engage with reflective writing in this
autoethnography.
Background to the Problem
As an educator and a student, I
recognise the importance of developing strong academic reflections. My
motivation to write about my experience arose mainly from my teaching practice,
where reflective writing was a vital component of class assessment. I often
incorporated different reflective activities in my classes; however, it was
observed that many students were unfamiliar with the reflective writing
process, and as a result, produced descriptive accounts of experiences or
events. These descriptive accounts do not meet the true purpose of reflective
writing, and as a result, students may find it either tedious or irrelevant,
lacking the motivation to engage actively in the process.
In the Canadian context,
reflective writing is integral across various educational levels, from K-12 to
post-secondary education (Rolheiser & Ross, 2013). Despite its recognised
importance, students continue to struggle with reflective writing, resulting in
superficial reflections that do not fully engage with the learning process. The
lack of explicit instruction in reflective writing contributes to this gap,
highlighting the need for pedagogical approaches that support the development
of these skills.
Reflective writing is
recognised as a fundamental component of higher education, serving as a bridge
between experiential learning and critical thinking. In recent years, educators
and researchers have increasingly emphasised the importance of developing
students’ reflective writing skills to enhance learning outcomes and promote deeper
engagement with course content. This literature review argues for the necessity of improving reflective
writing skills in higher education by synthesising existing research on
theoretical frameworks, types of reflections, pedagogical approaches, and
challenges students face during the reflective writing process.
Theoretical Frameworks
Scholars have discussed reflection
from different perspectives for various purposes. Some of the earliest insights
regarding the value of reflection come from John Dewey, who emphasised that
education should aim to promote thoughtful reflection, as true learning is not
automatic and occurs only when we reflect on our experiences (Holdo, 2023).
Dewey’s concept of reflective thinking involves actively, persistently, and
carefully evaluating any belief or purported body of knowledge in light of the
communities that endorse it and the conclusions it is likely to lead to in the
future. Dewey viewed experiential learning as a spiral rather than a cycle,
with learners progressing along a continuum of learning by using prior
knowledge to guide present and future decisions.
Kolb's theory of
experiential learning expands on Dewey's ideas. Students advance through four
stages of Kolb's experiential learning cycle: active experimentation, abstract
conceptualisation, reflective observation, and concrete experience (Kolb,
2014). These stages show how students' thinking becomes more sophisticated as
they go through the cycle, emphasising the value of reflection in the
educational process. Through reflective observation, students can advance their
learning to new heights by analysing and drawing inferences from events.
Additionally, Schon (2017)
defined reflection as the process by which a person deals with and attempts to
make sense of “puzzling, troubling, or interesting phenomena” in addition to
considering the understandings implicit in their actions, which they surface, criticise,
restructure, and embody in further action (p. 50). According to this
definition, reflective students analyse their methods, generate suggestions for
enhancing their performance, and implement those suggestions. This cycle is
known as admiration, action, and re-appreciation (Cheng, 2023).
Moreover,
Eyler and Giles (1999) developed the Five Cs of effective reflection:
connection, continuity, context, challenge, and coaching. Connection
encompasses a wide range of experiences, from institutional links to personal
connections with various social groups. Reflection leverages these connections
because experiential learning does not happen in a vacuum. Continuity refers to
reflecting at every stage of the process, with lifelong introspection being the
ultimate goal. Context considers the topic of reflection as well as the
location and timing of the reflection. Structural elements can significantly
improve or hinder reflective practice. Challenge is based on the idea that
while novel experiences foster more complex thought, they should be structured
to avoid being overwhelming. Lastly, coaching describes the assistance needed
for productive reflection. These
elements integrate reflective practices with experiential learning, emphasising
the importance of context and structured challenges to foster complex thought (Eyler & Giles, 1999). This theoretical
framework collectively highlights the integral role of reflection in enhancing
educational outcomes, forming the foundation for the necessity of improving
reflective writing skills in higher education.
Reflective writing refers to the construction
of new and deeper understanding and the articulation of knowledge in a more
meaningful way (Marshall, 2019; Pais Marden
& Herrington, 2022).
It is a form of writing in which the writer actively examines and evaluates
their own experiences, thoughts, or learning. Rather than simply describing an
event, reflective writing involves thinking critically about
what happened, why it happened, and what can be learned from it. It links experience with meaning (Ramlal & Augustin,
2020). As per Schon (2017), there are two primary forms of reflection that are
essential to learning and professional development: reflection on action and
reflection in action. While people are actively involved in a situation,
reflection in action takes place in real time. It entails developing a
conscious awareness of one's feelings, ideas, and behaviours as they emerge.
This kind of introspection improves a person's capacity for quick
decision-making and adaptation by enabling them to modify their behaviour in response
to current events (Cheng, 2023).
On the other hand,
reflection on action takes place after the experience or event has ended, when
people take a step back to think about and assess what happened. Retrospective
reflection is more intentional and introspective, requiring people to go back
over their experiences, assess the results, and consider different viewpoints
or methods (Dewey, 1933). It promotes greater understanding of the fundamental
causes of their behaviour, such as feelings, prejudices, and outside
influences. Individuals can develop new ideas for future actions and obtain a
deeper understanding of their professional practices by reflecting on their
actions (Moon, 2013). Together, both types of reflection enable ongoing
learning cycles that are vital for improving outcomes, abilities, and
accomplishing career objectives in many academic and occupational settings.
Teachers can help students develop reflective abilities by
implementing strategic teaching interventions in the classroom and scaffolding
skills pertinent to their current learning phase (Coulson & Harvey, 2013; Veine
et al., 2020). Students require assistance and encouragement to engage in
reflection; it is not something they do on their own. Support may depend on
several factors, such as prior reflection experience, language barriers, and
cultural variations in the conceptualisation of reflection. Therefore, teachers
should provide prompts or guiding questions to scaffold students' reflections
and focus their thinking (Moon, 2013). Incorporating peer review or group
discussions can encourage collaborative reflection and diverse perspectives. Furthermore,
offering feedback on students' reflections is essential to support their
development and help them refine their reflective skills.
Students' lack of experience with
reflective writing presents challenges when it comes to reflective writing (Kis
& Kartal, 2019; Veine et al., 2020). It has
been noticed that students often tend to be superficial and merely descriptive
in their reflections. Since students may not immediately recognise the
benefit of reflection and have varied levels of exposure to it, this difficulty
is emphasised in diverse settings (Dyment & O'Connell, 2010). It is therefore important to support students and make
them aware of the importance of reflection for their learning through clear
guidance and activities integrated into the course. It is also critical
to make sure that reflection exercises and learning objectives are
constructively aligned.
Thompson and Pascal (2012) specified that students may
have feelings of vulnerability when sharing their reflections, which could
impede candid and in-depth reflection. This may present additional challenges. To
foster openness and trust, educators must provide a secure and encouraging
environment. Furthermore, because reflective writing is subjective, grading it
can be difficult; therefore, in order to maintain
consistency and fairness, clear rubrics and standards are needed (Ryan &
Ryan, 2013).
By utilising scaffolding techniques, educators can create
an environment conducive to reflective practice, ultimately leading to improved
educational outcomes and more engaged learners. This study aims to enrich the
existing literature by providing a comprehensive, inclusive, and practical
framework for enhancing students’ reflective writing skills in higher
education, ultimately contributing to more effective and meaningful educational
experiences.
Methodology
Autoethnography is a qualitative research method
that combines personal experience with cultural, social, and academic analysis
to explore and reflect on a particular phenomenon (Adams et al., 2015). It is
particularly suited to this paper’s topic because it allows for an in-depth
exploration of the researcher’s experiences, providing a unique perspective on
the intersection of teaching and learning. By engaging in self-reflection, the
researcher is able to offer rich, personal insights that traditional research
methods may not capture. Given that this study focuses on both the personal
experiences of teaching and the reflective practices of students,
autoethnography provides a framework not only to analyse the personal,
subjective dimensions but also to understand them within a broader educational
context (Ellis,
2016).
I
chose autoethnography for this study because my personal teaching and learning
journey forms the core of the inquiry, and the complexity of these experiences
cannot be detached from my identity as both researcher and participant. Unlike
other qualitative approaches that examine participants externally,
autoethnography enables me to critically analyse my emotions, decisions, and
interactions from within the context in which they occur. This method allows me
to meaningfully connect personal narratives with broader educational themes,
making it the most appropriate approach for examining reflective practices,
learning dynamics, and transformative moments in my teaching experience.
Data Collection
The data were
collected mainly through reflections on my lived experiences as both a student
and a teacher, and also included reflections based on
self-observations, analysis of students’ reflective writing, and my feedback on
their work.
The
data were analysed holistically, integrating current memories and past events
to provide a deeper understanding of the evolving teaching and learning process
(Cooper & Lilyea, 2022). Rather than treating the
data as purely objective, I approached the analysis reflexively, considering
how my identity, positionality, and evolving understanding shaped both the
experiences themselves and my interpretation of them. Ethical considerations
were carefully addressed, ensuring the protection of the identities of my
school, university, and students, with no names mentioned other than my own.
An
Autoethnographic Narrative
I vaguely remember that during high
school in South Africa, we were occasionally asked to write descriptive pieces
after attending educational sessions led by guest speakers or going on school
trips. However, I cannot recall whether those write-ups included any true
elements of reflection. They were more about recounting what was said rather
than critically engaging with what we had learned.
When I first started
teaching at a primary school, teachers were required to submit weekly diaries
documenting their learning from professional development sessions and classroom
experiences. At that time, writing reflections felt like an extra task added to
an already demanding teaching schedule. Interestingly, the term ‘reflection’ was
never explicitly used, but we were provided with guiding questions to write
about our weekly teaching practices. This structure hinted at reflective
practice, yet the purpose behind it was not clear to me at the time.
It was not until my
journey as an MEd student that I heard the word ‘reflection’ formally
introduced. This happened during a teacher practicum course when our faculty
explicitly asked us to reflect on our teaching experiences. At that stage, I
approached it mechanically, simply answering the questions provided by the
instructor without a deeper understanding of what true reflection entailed. The
feedback I received was that my reflections were too descriptive and lacked the
evaluative depth expected at the graduate level. I often missed the critical
component of analysing my learning and considering the broader implications of
my experiences. As a graduate student, navigating much of my learning
independently, I was not sure how to improve my reflections beyond following
the given prompts. This early encounter with reflection planted the seed of
understanding, but it was not until later that I truly grasped its
significance.
Throughout my MEd
program, reflections became a consistent component of our coursework. Every
assignment seemed to include a reflective element. Even my thesis centred on
creating a writing portfolio, where reflection played a key role. Over the two
years, I slowly began to appreciate the value of reflection, though I did not
initially see how it translated into practical teaching applications. I vividly
recall our faculty urging us to maintain a diary during our teaching practicum,
a space to document our thoughts, challenges, and learning experiences. At the
time, I was naive and did not fully grasp the purpose behind this exercise. It
felt like just another task on an already full plate. I was also hesitant to
write openly about negative teaching practicum experiences, fearing that my
honesty might impact my assessment marks. This fear of judgment led me to write
cautiously, without truly engaging with what reflections were meant to uncover.
I was essentially going through the motions without questioning the deeper
purpose of reflective writing and wrote only positive aspects of my journey.
My transformative moment
came during my MEd thesis when I conducted action research aimed at developing
students' writing skills through the use of portfolios. As part of this study,
I was required to teach lessons in a school setting, and my students were asked
to include reflections in their portfolios. For the first time, I delved deeply
into the concept of reflection, not just how to write it, but how to teach it
effectively. This experience was eye-opening for me. I realised that throughout
my education, we had been tasked with writing reflections, but we were never
adequately taught how to engage in reflective writing meaningfully. This
revelation sparked my interest in teaching reflective practices, and I began to
explore how different activities, and pedagogical approaches could incorporate
reflective elements into my lessons.
After graduating, when I
began teaching at the university level, I quickly noticed that many of my
students struggled with writing meaningful reflections as well. Their
reflections were often purely descriptive, missing the critical, evaluative
aspects essential for genuine reflective practice. Many students lacked the
vocabulary to analyse their experiences effectively. Reflecting on this, I
recognised that the educational context in which I was working placed a heavy
emphasis on rote memorisation rather than critical thinking and
self-reflection. This was particularly apparent in fields like engineering and
commerce, where the focus was on formulas and finding the ‘right’ answer,
rather than reflecting on processes or personal growth. However, I primarily
taught nursing and education students, where reflection was a vital part of the
curriculum and professional practice.
To address this gap, I
revised my teaching approach. I dedicated more time to helping students
understand what reflection truly is and why it matters. Instead of simply
handing out reflective prompts, I spent class time discussing the purpose and
value of reflection. I introduced strategies to help students engage more
critically with their experiences. For instance, I emphasise that reflection is
not just a summary of events but a thoughtful process of considering what was
learned, how it affected their thinking, and how it might inform future
actions. I provide guiding questions to encourage deeper reflection, such as:
I also teach students to
analyse their experiences, not just describe them. Reflection involves
examining what went well, what did not, and exploring why certain outcomes
occurred. I encourage them to consider alternative actions and viewpoints,
fostering critical thinking. To further support this process, I share model
reflections and examples of effective reflective writing. We discuss these
examples in class, highlighting the balance between personal insights and
critical analysis, and how to connect experiences to broader academic concepts
or professional frameworks. I provide detailed rubrics that outline clear
expectations and offer regular feedback to students, focusing on how well they
analyse their experiences, connect them to learning goals, and draw meaningful
conclusions for personal and professional growth.
In addition to
individual feedback, I incorporate peer review activities, allowing students to
read and comment on each other’s reflections. I feel this is an important step
as peer feedback not only exposes students to different perspectives but also
helps them refine their own reflective practices. Creating a safe and
supportive environment for reflection is equally important. I make sure
students feel comfortable sharing their experiences without fear of judgment or
penalisation for expressing challenges or failures. I emphasise that reflection
is a learning tool, not a performance metric. I also give students ample time
and space for self-reflection, ensuring that the process is meaningful and not
rushed.
To make reflective writing more engaging, I
integrate technology into the process. I use platforms like Padlet, Google
Forms, and online discussion forums to facilitate reflective exercises, making
them interactive and accessible. These tools allow students to express their
reflections in diverse ways through text, images, or even audio recordings,
catering to different learning styles and preferences. For example, Padlet serves as a collaborative
reflection wall where students post short reflections during lessons, respond
to prompts such as What
challenged you today? What did you learn and how might you apply it? and engage with peers’ responses through
comments and reactions. This creates a sense of shared learning and community,
which is often missing in traditional pen-and-paper reflective journals. Google
Forms, on the other hand, allows me to design structured reflection prompts
that guide students from description toward deeper thinking questions like What surprised you? Why do you think this is important? or How has this experience changed your view? The submitted responses also provide quick
insights into students’ thinking, enabling timely feedback and instructional
adjustments. Moreover, online discussion forums promote dialogic reflection
where meaning-making occurs through interaction instead of isolated writing and
spontaneous responses. Compared to traditional reflection, these digital tools
make the process more dynamic, visually engaging, and less intimidating,
encouraging even quieter students to participate meaningfully.
As a PhD student now, I
see how reflective writing continues to play a critical role in my academic
journey. It’s not only a tool for my development as a researcher but also a way
to critically engage with my studies, analyse my evolving understanding, and
shape my future work. Reflection has become essential in examining how my
learning influences my research practices, methodologies, and academic
contributions. It serves as a foundation for continuous professional and personal
growth, both as a learner and an educator.
Reflecting
on my experiences, I realise that context and culture significantly influence
the development of reflective practices. In some countries, reflective writing
is still not fully embraced or understood within educational systems. During my
school years, it was not an integral part of the traditional curriculum, but
this is changing. Educational systems worldwide are increasingly incorporating
reflective activities, and teachers are being trained to understand and use
reflection in their teaching. There is growing awareness of the importance of
reflective practice, yet the question remains: Are these reflections
truly serving their intended purpose? Are students and educators
genuinely engaging with reflection in a meaningful way, or is it just another
box to check off on an assignment sheet? These are questions I
continue to explore in my own practice as both an educator and a researcher.
Analysis and Meaning-Making
This
autoethnographic exploration of my journey with reflective writing highlights
the transformative nature of reflective practice in both personal and
professional contexts. The evolution of my understanding of reflection, from a
task that initially felt burdensome to a critical tool for growth, illustrates
how reflective writing is shaped by educational contexts, cultural
expectations, and personal experiences.
Initially, my exposure to reflection in high school,
primary school teaching in South Africa, and later as a graduate student was
limited and superficial. Although reflective activities were embedded in
various assignments, there was a lack of explicit instruction on how to engage
in meaningful reflection. This aligns with the literature suggesting that
students often struggle with reflective writing due to inadequate guidance and
support (Ryan, 2015). My early reflections were descriptive, focusing on
recounting events rather than critically analysing them. The feedback I
received during my MEd studies, emphasising the absence of evaluative elements
in my writing, became a pivotal moment in recognising the depth of reflection
demands. This experience mirrored Ryan’s (2015) assertion that reflective
writing is often treated as a routine task, rather than a means to engage in
deeper critical thinking.
The shift in my reflective practice occurred during my
MEd programme, where I engaged in an action research study aimed at developing
students' writing skills through portfolios. This writing experience allowed me
to engage with reflection not only as a student but also as an educator
facilitating reflection in others. It became evident that reflection is not an
innate skill but one that requires positive reinforcement and practice (Sudriman et al., 2024). As I guided students in reflective
writing, I realised the need for guidance and explicit teaching to ensure
meaningful engagement. This was especially important because many students,
like myself, initially struggled with reflecting
beyond surface-level descriptions. The realisation that my students, much like
me, struggled with reflective writing underscored the systemic gaps in teaching
this skill. In educational systems that prioritise rote learning and factual
recall, reflective practice is often underutilised or misunderstood (Moon,
2013). The lack of scaffolding to develop reflective thinking further
exacerbates this issue.
As I transitioned into university-level teaching, I
recognised the importance of embedding reflective practices into my curriculum,
particularly for nursing and education students, where reflection is integral
to professional development. By revising my teaching approach to include
explicit instruction on reflection, providing guiding questions, and creating a
supportive environment, I observed significant improvements in my students'
reflective abilities (Coulson & Harvey, 2013; Veine et al., 2020). In particular,
the use of scaffolding strategies such as sharing model reflections and using
rubrics to set clear expectations helped students understand how to move from
descriptive to evaluative reflection (Smith, 2024). The incorporation of peer
review and technology-based platforms like Padlet and online discussion forums
further enriched the reflective process, allowing for diverse perspectives and
more dynamic engagement. Peer review opportunities and online tools not only
provided students with various modes of expression but also encouraged
collaborative reflection, where they could learn from each other's experiences
and insights (Boase-Jelinek et al., 2013).
In my current experience as a PhD student, reflection
continues to play a critical role in my academic and professional growth.
Reflection has evolved into a tool for critically engaging with my research,
understanding my learning trajectory, and shaping my future work. This mirrors the
broader scholarly consensus on the role of reflective practice in fostering
critical thinking, self-awareness, and lifelong learning (Cheng, 2023).
Reflection, in this context, has become more than a form of assessment; it is a
cornerstone of my ongoing development as a researcher and an educator. As I
refine my research practices and methodologies, reflecting on my experiences
enables me to adapt, adjust, and improve my work with greater awareness and
intention.
Reflecting on the cultural and contextual factors
influencing reflective practices reveals that while reflection is gaining
prominence globally, its implementation and reception vary significantly. In
some educational systems, reflection remains a checkbox activity rather than a
transformative process (Chan & Lee, 2021). This raises critical questions
about how educators can foster genuine engagement with reflective practices.
Are we, as educators and researchers, creating environments where reflection is
meaningful, or are we perpetuating superficial compliance with reflective
tasks? In my own practice, I have sought to provide my students with
opportunities to engage with reflection more holistically, with an emphasis on
its transformative potential. However, I am also aware that the institutional
context and educational culture can heavily influence how reflection is
embraced or sidelined (Chan & Lee, 2021). This is particularly true in
fields where technical skills are prioritised over personal or professional
development, such as engineering or commerce. In such contexts, the emphasis on
finding the "correct" answers often limits opportunities for
reflective engagement. Therefore, it is essential that educators across
disciplines intentionally cultivate an environment where reflection is seen as
integral to learning, not just an additional task to complete.
Conclusion
In conclusion, this
autoethnographic narrative illustrates how my understanding of reflection
evolved over time, from viewing it as a task embedded in school assignments to
recognising it as a meaningful process that supports critical thinking,
professional growth, and identity development as an educator and researcher. My
experience reveals that reflective writing is not an innate skill but one that
develops through explicit modelling, guided practice, and intentional
scaffolding. The critical shift occurred when I moved from completing
reflections as a requirement to teaching and facilitating reflective writing
for others. This dual perspective helped me understand reflection not only as a
personal learning tool but as a pedagogical approach that requires structure,
feedback, and a safe environment to thrive.
The
analysis suggests that students, much like I once did, struggle with reflection
when they are not taught what meaningful reflective engagement looks like.
Technology integration, modelling, reflective prompts, and multimodal platforms
can reduce barriers by making the reflective process more interactive,
accessible, and collaborative. Tools and platforms such as Padlet, Google Forms,
and online forum discussions provide space for dialogue and self-expression,
supporting deeper thinking beyond descriptive recounting. Moreover, the critical
narrative highlights how institutional culture and disciplinary norms shape
students’ willingness to reflect openly. When assessment is tied to perfection
rather than growth, reflection risks becoming superficial, a checkbox rather
than transformative learning.
Broadly,
this inquiry emphasises the need for educators to move beyond assigning
reflection toward teaching reflection.
Intentional scaffolding, clear expectations, authentic feedback, and
opportunities for peer dialogue enable learners to develop reflective
competence. At a broader pedagogical level, this narrative contributes to
ongoing conversations about fostering reflective literacy as an essential
component of higher education, particularly within professional disciplines
such as education, nursing, and applied sciences.
As
I continue to navigate reflective writing in my PhD journey, I am reminded that
reflection remains iterative, constantly evolving as one’s experiences,
contexts, and identities shift. This work invites further exploration into how
reflective writing can be cultivated across disciplines, how technology can further
enhance reflective practice, and how educators can ensure that reflection moves
beyond description toward critical meaning-making. Ultimately, meaningful
reflection is not a product, but a habit of mind that sustains growth, inquiry,
and transformation throughout one’s academic and professional life.
References
Adams, T. E., Holman
Jones, S. L., & Ellis, C. (2015). Autoethnography: Understanding qualitative
research. Oxford
University Press.
Adie, L., & Tangen, D. (2014). The
use of multimodal technologies to enhance reflective writing in teacher
education. In M. Orey (Ed.), Teaching reflective learning in higher
education: A systematic approach using pedagogic patterns (pp. 127-138).
Springer International Publishing.
Ash, S. L., &
Clayton, P. H. (2009). Generating, deepening, and documenting learning: The
power of critical reflection in applied learning. Journal of Applied Learning in Higher Education, 1(1), 25-48. https://scholarworks.indianapolis.iu.edu/items/5f06a791-b5c1-4da2-95c7-120df70f5a65
Bharuthram, S. (2018). Reflecting on the process of teaching reflection in higher education. Reflective Practice, 19(6), 806-817. https://doi.org/10.1080/14623943.2018.1539655
Boase-Jelinek, D., Parker, J., & Herrington, J. (2013). Student reflection and learning through peer reviews. Issues in Educational Research, 23(2), 119-131. https://www.iier.org.au/iier23/boase-jelinek.pdf
Chan, C. K., & Lee, K. K. (2021). Reflection literacy: A multilevel
perspective on the challenges of using reflections in higher education through
a comprehensive literature review. Educational Research Review, 32, 100376. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.edurev.2020.100376
Cheng, M.
(2023). Transition skills and strategies: Critical self-reflection. The Quality Assurance Agency for Higher Education. https://www.enhancementthemes.ac.uk/docs/ethemes/student-transitions/critical-self-reflection.pdf
Cooper, R., & Lilyea, B. V. (2022). I’m interested in autoethnography, but how do I do it? The Qualitative Report, 27(1), 197-208. https://doi.org/10.46743/2160-3715/2022.5288
Coulson, D., & Harvey, M. (2013). Scaffolding student reflection for experience-based learning: a framework. Teaching in Higher Education, 18, 401-413. https://doi.org/10.1080/13562517.2012.752726
Crane, C.,
& Sosulski, M. J. (2020). Staging transformative
learning across collegiate language curricula: Student perceptions of
structured reflection for language learning. Foreign Language Annals, 53(1),
69-95. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/flan.12437
Dewey, J.
(1933). How we think: A restatement of the relation of reflective
thinking to the educative process. DC Heath.
Dyment, J. E., & O’Connell, T. S. (2010). The quality of reflection in student journals: A review of limiting and enabling factors. Innovative Higher Education, 35(4), 233-244. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10755-010-9143-y
Ellis, C. (2016). Revision: Autoethnographic reflections on life and
work.
Routledge.
Eyler, J., & Giles, D. (1999). Where's the learning
in service-learning? Jossey-Bass.
Holdo, M. (2023). Critical reflection:
John Dewey’s relational view of transformative learning. Journal of
Transformative Education, 21(1), 9-25. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/15413446221086727
Kis, S., & Kartal, G. (2019). No pain no gain:
reflections on the promises and challenges of embedding reflective practices in
large classes. Reflective Practice, 20,
637-653. https://doi.org/10.1080/14623943.2019.1651715.
Kolb, D. A. (2014). Experiential learning: Experience as the source of learning and development. FT Press.
Marshall,
T. (2019). The concept of reflection: A systematic review and thematic
synthesis across professional contexts. Reflective Practice, 20(3), 395-415. https://doi.org/10.1080/14623943.2019.1622520
Moon, J. A. (2013). Reflection in
learning and professional development: Theory and practice (1st ed.).
Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203822296
Pais
Marden, M., & Herrington, J. (2022). Encouraging reflective practice through learning
portfolios in an authentic online foreign language learning environment. Reflective Practice, 23(2), 177-189. https://doi.org/10.1080/14623943.2021.2001321
Ramlal, A.,
& Augustin, D. S. (2020). Engaging students in reflective writing: An
action research project. Educational Action Research,
28(3), 518-533. https://eric.ed.gov/?id=EJ1260449
Rolheiser, C., & Ross, J. A. (2013). Student self-evaluation: What
research says and what practice shows. In M. Grover (Ed.), Student
assessment and learning. Canadian Education Association.
Ryan, M. E. (2015). Teaching reflective learning in
higher education. Springer.
Ryan, M., & Ryan, M. (2013). Theorising a model for
teaching and assessing reflective learning in higher education. Higher
Education Research & Development, 32(2), 244-257. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/07294360.2012.661704
Schon, D. A. (2017). The reflective
practitioner: How professionals think in action. Routledge.
Smith, T. (2024). Using rubrics to guide reflective
writing in nursing education. Journal of Nursing Primary Health Care, JNPHC-103.
Sudirman, A., Gemilang, A.
V., Kristanto, T. M. A., Robiasih, R. H., Nugroho, A.
D., Karjono, J. S., ... & Rais, B. (2024).
Reinforcing reflective practice through reflective writing in higher education:
A systematic review. International Journal of Learning,
Teaching and Educational Research, 23(5), 454-474.
Taylor, E.
(2023). Promoting student reflection through reflective writing tasks. Journal on Empowering Teaching Excellence, 7(1), Article 6. https://doi.org/10.26077/eafb-b4ea
Thompson, N., & Pascal, J. (2012). Developing
critically reflective practice. Reflective Practice, 13(2),
311-325.
Veine, S., Anderson, M. K., Andersen, N. H., Espenes, T. C., Soyland, T. B., Wallin, P., & Reams, J. (2020). Reflection as a core student learning activity in higher education-Insights from nearly two decades of academic development. International Journal for Academic Development, 25(2), 147-161. https://doi.org/10.1080/1360144X.2019.1659797